goodpods top 100 true crime podcasts Goodpods Top 100 True Crime Podcasts Listen now to The Signature: The Life and Death of Mic
a Miller podcast

Craig Price: The Teenage Serial Killer Who Shocked Rhode Island

Craig Price: The Teenage Serial Killer Who Shocked Rhode Island

In the quiet suburban neighborhoods of Warwick, Rhode Island, evil lurked behind an unexpected face. Craig Chandler Price, a teenager with a disarming smile and athletic prowess, harbored a darkness that would shock the nation and change the face of juvenile justice forever.

A Community Shattered

On a crisp September morning in 1989, Marie Bouchard's world imploded. Concerned about her daughter Joan Heaton and grandchildren Jennifer and Melissa, she made the fateful decision to check on their home. What awaited her was a scene of unimaginable horror – a blood-soaked tableau of brutality that would haunt Warwick for decades to come.

Joan Heaton, 39, lay crumpled beneath blood-stained sheets, her body bearing the marks of 57 savage stab wounds. Nearby, 10-year-old Jennifer and 8-year-old Melissa had met equally gruesome fates. The youngest, Melissa, had been stabbed with such ferocity that a knife blade remained embedded in her neck, her skull crushed by a kitchen stool.

Joan Heaton’s home in Buttonwoods

As investigators reeled from the savagery, a chilling realization dawned – this was not the first time death had visited Buttonwoods.

A Killer Emerges from the Shadows

Two years earlier, in the sweltering summer of 1987, 27-year-old Rebecca Spencer had been found stabbed 58 times in her home, just doors away from the Heaton residence. The case had gone cold, leaving a community on edge and a killer emboldened.

Rebecca Spencer

Little did anyone suspect that the perpetrator of these heinous acts was not some hardened criminal, but a boy barely into his teens. Craig Price, at just 13 years old, had committed his first murder. By 15, he had claimed four lives, earning him the grim distinction of being the youngest serial killer in U.S. history.

The Mask of Innocence Slips

Price, a hulking figure despite his youth, had always stood out. Nicknamed "Ironman" for his football prowess, he seemed an unlikely suspect. Yet as detectives dug deeper, a disturbing pattern emerged. Petty thefts, drug use, and a history of violence painted a picture of a troubled soul spiraling towards darkness.

15-year-old Craig Price

It was a keen-eyed patrolman who finally connected the dots. Noticing a suspicious cut on Price's hand, investigators brought him in for questioning. What followed was a confession so chilling in its nonchalance that it would haunt seasoned detectives for years to come.

A Justice System Unprepared

Price's arrest exposed a glaring flaw in Rhode Island's juvenile justice system. Despite the brutality of his crimes, state law dictated that he be tried as a minor. This meant that at 21, Craig Price could walk free, his record wiped clean.

The prospect of Price's release galvanized the community. Victims' families, law enforcement, and citizens united in their determination to keep the "Warwick Slasher" behind bars. Their efforts would lead to sweeping changes in how Rhode Island, and eventually other states, dealt with juvenile offenders accused of heinous crimes.

A Legacy of Pain and Change

Today, Craig Price remains incarcerated, not for the murders that shocked Rhode Island, but for a series of violent infractions committed behind bars. His case serves as a chilling reminder that evil can wear many faces, even that of a child.

The wounds inflicted on Warwick have never fully healed. Rebecca Spencer, Joan Heaton, Jennifer, and Melissa – their names are etched into the community's collective memory. Their tragic stories continue to fuel debates on juvenile justice, rehabilitation, and the nature of evil itself.

As Craig Price approaches his fifth decade of life, much of it spent behind bars, one question lingers – can a child who commits monstrous acts ever truly be redeemed? The answer, like the man himself, remains locked away, a dark enigma that continues to haunt Rhode Island and the nation.